Cessna pilot goes into Spiraling Turn & Rapid Descent Mid-air

A Cessna 182 departing Monterey encountered a violent upset after the pilot reported a rough ride and asked to return. The aircraft then dropped thousands of feet while entering a steep spiral.

The First Upset

The aircraft climbed through about 4,500 feet when the pilot reported a rough ride and requested a return to Monterey Regional Airport. Shortly afterward, the altitude fell to approximately 1,800 feet as the aircraft entered a dangerous spiraling turn.

NorCal controllers immediately began working the aircraft. Controller Ryan Nines repeatedly told the pilot to level the wings while monitoring the aircraft against the minimum vectoring altitude.

The Autopilot Complication

A pilot on the frequency suggested using the autopilot if it was available to help keep the wings level. The Cessna pilot engaged it, but the aircraft's equipment problems made the automation difficult to use.

Controllers Keep the Aircraft Together

Controllers coordinated between sectors, considered nearby weather and worked to get the aircraft toward visual conditions. The Cessna experienced additional upsets and altitude losses, but each time controllers identified the unintended turn and instructed the pilot to stop rolling.

The first indication to the controller was the pilot's report of a rough ride. The aircraft was still at about 4,500 feet when the pilot requested a return to Monterey. The subsequent drop to about 1,800 feet transformed a routine return into an immediate control emergency.

Nines and the other controllers used repeated, simple instructions to get the pilot to stop the roll. Other pilots on the frequency also recognized what was happening and offered assistance. The emergency became a coordinated effort between the controller team and pilots listening on the same frequency.

The NATCA record gives the aircraft registration as N5188T and identifies the route as Monterey Regional Airport to Lincoln Regional Airport. It also identifies Ryan Nines, William Hoppe Jr. and Luis Ramirez as the controllers involved in the save.

The event is a useful example of why simple instructions can matter during an upset. Nines repeatedly reduced the task to the immediate control problem—level the wings—while other controllers worked on weather and alternate options.

N5188T, try to level your wings, just level your wings.

The NATCA account records repeated altitude losses and unintentional turns, making the controller's simple instruction to level the wings a recurring part of the recovery. Other controllers simultaneously searched for weather information and a route toward VFR conditions.

“During these transmissions, aircraft on the same frequency became aware that this pilot was in danger.”

Accident Facts

Timeline

Sources